              
|
EVALUATION
OF DENDROBIUM CROSSES
INVOLVING FOUR NEW AMPHIDIPLOID PARENTS
|
Abstract
Four
new amphidiploid dendrobium plants became available for breeding:
K706-18 and D184-4N, having Dendrobium discolor in their background,
and K916-57 and K927-27, having D. gouldii in their background.
Twenty-four crosses were made utilizing the four amphidiploids
to possibly identify cross combinations that might complement
existing cultivars in reducing the peaks and valleys of seasonal
flower yields.
Among
the eight progenies involving K706-18 as a parent, K1299 (K706-18
x D. Jaquelyn Thomas D192) gave the best results and therefore
will be released for trail by growers. K1323 (K706-18 x D.
Jaquelyn Concert D239-1), which produced attractive red flowers,
will be recommended for trial as potted plants. K1430 (D184-4N
x K916-57), K1426 (K440-50 x K916-57), and K1427 (K927-27
x D168-12) produced the best results among their related crosses.
These crosses will be offered to growers for trail to complement
the commercial cultivars UH232, UH503, and UH507 in broadening
seasonal yields.
Introduction
Evaluation
of the dendrobium crosses to develop new cultivars for commercial
cutflower production has been an ongoing activity of the dendrobium
breeding program at the University of Hawaii. In 1989 the
results of an experiment comparing 16 seed-propagated amphidiploid
dendrobium progenies were summarized (Kamemoto et al., 1989).
The cross UH800 (Uniwai Mist) combined many desirable
characteristics and therefore was released to dendrobium growers
to complement the cultivars UH44 (Uniwai Blush),
UH232 (Uniwai Supreme), UH306 (Uniwai Pearl),
UH503 (Uniwai Prince), and UH507 (Uniwai
Princess) developed earlier (Kamemoto 1985, Kamemoto
et al. 1976, Kamemoto and Bobisud 1979, Kamemoto and Kunisaki
1980, Kamemoto and McConnell 1982).
A
few new amphidiploid plants have become available for breeding,
namely K706-18 (D. Manoa Ruby), D184-4N (D. superbiens), K916-57
(D. Jaquelyn Thomas), and K927-27 (D. Jaquelyn Thomas). These
amphidiploids were crossed to several other amphidiploid plants
in hope of identifying desirable new cross combinations that
might complement existing cultivars in reducing the peaks
and valleys of seasonal yields.
Materials
and Methods
New
amphidiploid parent plants
The
origin and genome characteristics of the four new amphidiploid
breeding plants are as follows:
|
K706-18
(D. Manoa Ruby) This amphidiploid has a slightly
different genome makeup than D. Jaquelyn Thomas and
D. Neo Hawaii in that it contains the D. discolor genome
instead of the D. gouldii genome of D. Jaquelyn Thomas
or the D. grantii genome of D. Neo Hawaii. K706-18
originated from a cross between a tetraploid D. discolor
and tetraploid D. Mae Teramoto, a dark purple D. phalaenopsis-type
hybrid.
|
|
D184-4N (D. superbiens, 4N) D. superbiens is
a natural hybrid between D. phalaenopsis and D. discolor.
Triploid Louis Bleriot arose from the cross
between D. superbiens and D. phalaenopsis, while tetraploid
Pompadour is a hybrid between Louis
Bleriot and D. phalaenopsis. We obtained diploid
D. superbiens Surperba from Kodama Orchid
Nursery (Waianae, HI) and induced chromosome doubling
by treating protocorm-like bodies in tissue culture
with colchicine.
|
|
K916-57 (D. Jaquleyn Thomas, 4N) In our earlier
attempt to breed for resistance to necrosis resulting
from infection with cymbidium mosaic virus, we crossed
diploid D. phalaenopsis Mauna Loa, exhibiting
no floral necrosis, with D. gouldii Chings.
The hybrid offspring inoculated with cymbidium mosaic
virus also exhibited no necrosis (Kobayashi and Kamemoto
1989). A selected diploid individual infected with virus
was tissue cultured, and the protocorm-like bodies were
treated with colchicines to develop the induced amphidiploid.
|
|
K927-27 (D. Jaquelyn Thomas, 4N) Diploid D.
phalaenopsis Kosaki with purple flowers
crossed to diploid D. gouldii Chings
resulted in offspring that lacked viral necrosis, similar
to cross K916. A selected diploid individual was tissue
cultured and the protocorm like bodies were treated
with colchicine to induce the amphidiploid.
|
|
Table 1. Amphidiploid plants used in
crosses with the four new amphidiploid parents.
|
Plant number
|
Registered hybrid name
|
Origin
|
|
Y166-1
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
An amphidiploid seedling selection among an otherwise
diploid progeny.
|
|
K44-50
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
A seedling selection from the selfed progeny of Y166-1.
|
|
K159-19, 21
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
Selections from the second selfed generation of Y166-1.
|
|
0580-4N
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
Spontaneous doubling in tissue culture of a diploid
hybrid.
|
|
NH-4N
|
Neo Hawaii
|
Spontaneous doubling in tissue culture of a diploid
hybrid.
|
|
D168-12
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
A seedling selection from selfing an amphidiploid
hybrid.
|
|
D192
|
Jaquelyn Thomas
|
Spontaneous doubling in tissue culture of a diploid
hybrid obtained from Bangkok Flowers Centre.
|
|
D239-1
|
Jaquelyn Concert
|
A tetraploid seedling with red-purple flowers obtained
from a grower in Hilo.
|
|
Crosses
The
parent plants used in producing 24 crosses with the four new
amphidiploid plants are listed in Table 1, along with their
registered hybrid names and origins. Two University of Hawaii
cultivars released earlier UH232 and UH503, served as controls.
Pollinations with K706-18 were made between February and May
1988 while all other pollinations were made between January
and April 1991. Seeds were germinated aseptically about three
months after pollination, and seedlings were transflasked
three months later. Seedlings were transplanted into community
pots about six months after germination, and into 2-inch pots
about six months later. About 9 to 10 months later, seedlings
were moved into 6-inch black plastic pots containing no. 3
crushed blue rock as a medium.
The
amphidiploid progenies were arranged on benches in a polypropylene
shadehouse (30 percent shade). Twenty-two plants per cross
were observed.
Raceme
(spray) yield was recorded weekly for K706-18 progenies from
July 1990 until December 1993, while progenies of the other
three amphidiploids were observed from June 1993 to June 1996.
Scape length was measured from the point of attachment to
the pseudobulbs to the lowest flower, while raceme length
was measured from the point of attachment to the pseudobulbs
to the tip of the raceme. Other flower characteristics measured
were flower width, pedicel length, number of flowers per raceme,
and percentage bud drop. The vase life was expressed as the
number of days until 50 percent of the flowers on the raceme
wilted or dropped off. At the end of the experiment the height
of the tallest pseudobulbs was recorded.
Data
were analyzed using SAS software (SAS Institute, Cary NC).
Analysis of variance was conducted for each characteristic
using the general linear model procedure. Bud drop percentage
was transformed with the arc sine transformation prior to
analysis. Differences among treatment means at the 95% probability
level were calculated using Duncans multiple range test.
Results
and discussion
Crosses
with K706-18
|
 |
 |
 |
| Den.
Manoa Ruby x Jaquelyn Thomas 'D192' (UH1299) |
|
Den.
Manoa Ruby x Jaquelyn Thomas 'D192' (UH1299) |
| The
performance of crosses involving K706-18 as a parent is summarized
in Tables 2 and 3. The highest yield was obtained with K1299,
having D192 as the other parent, while the lowest yields were
obtained with K1304 and K1306, having NH-4N and 0580-4N, respectively,
as the other parent. |
Table 2. Mean raceme yield per plant
from July 1990 to December 1993, scape length, raceme length, and
number of flowers per raceme of K706-18 progenies.
|
Cross number
|
Cross
|
Raceme yield (per plant)
|
Scape length (cm)
|
Raceme length (cm)
|
Number of flowers per raceme
|
|
K1290
|
K159-21 x K706-18
|
18.7 abz
|
18.6 bc
|
51.5 a
|
15.1 ab
|
|
K1299
|
D192 x K706-18
|
20.3 a
|
19.3 a
|
51.9 a
|
15.4 ab
|
|
K1302
|
K159-19 x K706-18
|
17.2 bc
|
18.7
a
|
52.5 a
|
15.0 ab
|
|
K1303
|
Y166-1 x K706-18
|
17.7 abc
|
17.4 bc
|
52.9 a
|
15.3 ab
|
|
K1304
|
NH-4N x K706-18
|
14.3 d
|
19.9 a
|
54.2 a
|
14.5 b
|
|
K1306
|
O580-4N x K706-18
|
15.1 cd
|
19.5 a
|
51.9 a
|
13.2 c
|
|
K1308
|
D168-12 x K706-18
|
15.0 cd
|
16.5 c
|
53.4 a
|
15.8 a
|
|
K1323
|
K706-18 x D239-1
|
17.4 bc
|
19.2 a
|
54.0 a
|
14.9 ab
|
|
K1281
|
UH232
|
16.9 bcd
|
18.7 a
|
54.0 a
|
15.7 ab
|
Z Mean separation by Duncans multiple range test.
Any two means having a common letter are not significantly different
at the 5 percent level.
Table 3. Flower width, pedicel length,
vase life, percentage of bud drop and plant height of K706-18 progenies.
|
Cross number
|
Cross
|
Flower width (cm)
|
Pedicel length (cm)
|
Vase life (days)
|
Bud drop (%)
|
Mean plant height (cm)
|
|
K1290
|
K159-21 x K706-18
|
6.6 az
|
4.0 d
|
17.7 a
|
0.98 abc
|
82.0 c
|
|
K1299
|
D192 x K706-18
|
6.8 a
|
5.2 a
|
19.6 a
|
0.99 abc
|
106.4 a
|
|
K1302
|
K159-19 x K706-18
|
6.6 a
|
4.3 bc
|
17.2 ab
|
0.42 c
|
81.4 cd
|
|
K1303
|
Y166-1 x K706-18
|
6.0 bc
|
4.4 bc
|
19.4 a
|
0.88 abc
|
81.1 cd
|
|
K1304
|
NH-4N x K706-18
|
6.1 b
|
4.3 bc
|
19.6 a
|
0.98 abc
|
78.7 cd
|
|
K1306
|
O580-4N x K706-18
|
5.9 bcd
|
4.1 cd
|
16.9 ab
|
0.64 bc
|
80.7 cd
|
|
K1308
|
D168-12 x K706-18
|
5.6 d
|
4.4 b
|
18.0 a
|
1.44 a
|
72.1 d
|
|
K1323
|
K706-18 x D239-1
|
5.6 cd
|
4.3 bc
|
14.5 b
|
0.78 abc
|
77.4 cd
|
|
K1281
|
UH232
|
5.9 bcd
|
4.4 bc
|
19.5 a
|
1.19 ab
|
91.3 b
|
Z Mean separation by Duncans multiple range test.
Any two means having a common letter are not significantly different
at the 5 percent level.
|
No
differences were observed for raceme length, but statistically
significant differences were observed for scape length. However,
the magnitude of the differences were small, and they probably
do not have any practical significance.
The
number of flowers per spray was about equal for most crosses,
except for K1304 and K1306, which had fewer flowers. Flower
size expressed as flower width (natural spread of flowers)
was largest for K1290, K1299, and K1302, which had K159-21,
D192, and K159-19, respectively as the second parent. The
pedicel was longest in K1299, undoubtedly an influence of
the D192 parent.
With
the exception of K1323, with a vase life of 14.5 days, the
vase lives of 16.9 to 19.6 days for all other crosses did
not differ statistically. Bud drop percentage was less than
1.5 for all crosses. The pseudobulb height showed variation,
from 106.4 cm for K1299 to 72.1 cm for K1308.
Slight
variation in flower size and color was observed among individuals
within progenies. Both K1299, with red-purple (RHSCC 72B)
flowers, and K1323, with dark red-purple (RHSCC 71A) flowers,
showed slight variation among offspring.
Based
on all characters enumerated above, two crosses appear worthy
of trial by growers. K1299, a cross between K706-18 and Jaquelyn
Thomas D192, produced long racemes, numerous flowers per raceme,
relatively large flowers, fairly uniform flower color, good
vase life, and a low bud drop. A weakness might be the tall
pseudobulbs. The performance of K1299 was equal to that of
the control, K1281 (UH232). The seasonality is shown in Figure
1. K1299 might well complement the cultivar UH503 (Uniwai
Prince), which is now under commercial production.
The
major attribute of K1323 is the attractive, reddish-purple
flower resulting from the combination of dark purple (K706-18)
and bright reddish-purple (Jaquelyn Concert, D239-1). Unfortunately,
the vase life of K1323 is shorter than the other crosses.
Because of attractive red flowers, K1323 was released
earlier for trial. As shown in Figure 1, flowering is spread
throughout the year, without the pronounced peaks of other
PPCC-type cultivars. Perhaps K1323 is better suited as a potted
plant cultivar than as a cutflower cultivar.
|
Figure
1. Monthly raceme yields of K1299, K1323, and K1281 (UH232)
|
Crosses
with D184-4N
|
 |
 |
|
UH1430
|
UH1430
|
| The characteristics
of crosses involving D184-4N (D. superbiens) and K1440 (UH503)
serving as control are shown in tables 4 and 5. Most of the
crosses had similar results, except K1429, which exhibited high
bud drop (10.1 percent), and K1442, which had low yield (9.8
racemes per plant). |
Table 4. Mean raceme yield per plant from July 1993
to June 1996, scape length, raceme length and flowers per raceme
of D. superbiens (D184-4N) progenies.
|
Cross number
|
Cross
|
Raceme yield (per plant)
|
Scape length (cm)
|
Raceme length (cm)
|
Number of flowers per raceme
|
|
K1428
|
D184-4N x K927-27
|
11.5 cdz
|
16.3 a
|
51.8 a
|
15.2 bc
|
|
K1429
|
D184-4N x D168-12
|
10.5 cd
|
16.0 a
|
49.1 a
|
15.6
ab
|
|
K1430
|
D184-4N x K916-57
|
14.3 a
|
16.2 a
|
48.0
a
|
15.6 ab
|
|
K1431
|
D184-4N x NH-4N
|
12.1 bc
|
17.8 a
|
47.7 a
|
14.2 c
|
|
K1442
|
D184-4N x K706-18
|
9.8 d
|
17.6 a
|
51.0 a
|
15.1 bc
|
|
K1443
|
D184-4N x O580-4N
|
11.2 cd
|
18.0 a
|
46.2 a
|
14.1 c
|
|
K1444
|
D184-4N x K44-50
|
14.0 ab
|
22.0 a
|
51.9 a
|
16.8 a
|
|
K1440
|
UH503
|
11.5 cd
|
15.4 a
|
45.8 a
|
14.1 c
|
Z Mean separation by Duncans multiple range test.
Any two means having a common letter are not significantly different
at the 5 percent level.
Table 5. Flower width, pedicel length,
vase life, percentage of bud drop, and plant height of D. superbiens
(D184-4N) progenies.
|
Cross number
|
Cross
|
Flower width (cm)
|
Pedicel length (cm)
|
Vase life (days)
|
Bud drop (%)
|
Mean plant height (cm)
|
|
K1428
|
D184-4N x K927-27
|
5.9 abz
|
4.2 ab
|
22.7 a
|
1.01 b
|
84.8 a
|
|
K1429
|
D184-4N x D168-12
|
5.4 b
|
3.6 c
|
21.0 a
|
10.07 a
|
84.4 a
|
|
K1430
|
D184-4N x K916-57
|
6.0 a
|
4.2 ab
|
16.0 a
|
1.72
b
|
83.2 a
|
|
K1431
|
D184-4N x NH-4N
|
5.5 ab
|
4.1 abc
|
24.2 a
|
1.44 b
|
84.5 a
|
|
K1442
|
D184-4N x K706-18
|
5.5 ab
|
3.7 bc
|
18.5 a
|
3.11 b
|
79.5 a
|
|
K1443
|
D184-4N x O580-4N
|
5.7 ab
|
3.9 abc
|
25.0 a
|
1.82 b
|
80.5 a
|
|
K1444
|
D184-4N x K44-50
|
5.4 b
|
4.0 abc
|
21.8 a
|
1.29 b
|
88.5 s
|
|
K1440
|
UH503
|
5.6 ab
|
4.5 a
|
20.1 a
|
1.31 b
|
66.5 b
|
Z Mean separation by Duncans multiple range test.
Any two means having a common letter are not significantly different
at the 5 percent level.
|
Some
variation in size and color of flowers was observed within
progenies. K1431, having NH-4N as a parent, showed greater
variation among offspring than other crosses. K1442, having
K706-18 as a parent, produced several distorted racemes.
K1444,
having K44-50 as a parent, and K1430, having K916-57 as a
parent, outperformed all crosses including the control, K1440
(Uh503). Raceme yield, number of flowers per raceme, and seasonality
were similar (Fig. 2). Because the flower color of K1430 was
slightly darker purple than that of K1444, and similar to
that of UH503, K1430 will be recommended for trial by interested
growers.
|
Figure
2. Monthly raceme yields of K1430 and K1440 (UH503)

|
Crosses
with K916-57
The
results of crosses with K916-57 (D. Jaquelyn Thomas K916-57)
are presented in Tables 6 and 7. K1426, having K44-50 as a
parent, along with the reciprocal cross (K1441) outperformed
UH232 (K1439) in raceme yield, raceme length, and number of
flowers. The crosses having 0580-4N as a parent (K1412, K1432,
K1438) had fewer flowers and flowers with shorter pedicels
than the crosses involving K44-50. The size of the flowers,
vase lives, and bud drop percentage of all crosses did not
differ.
|
Table 6. Mean raceme yield per plant
from June 1993 to June 1996, scape length, raceme length and number
of flowers per raceme of D. Jaquelyn Thomas K916-57 progenies.
|
Cross number
|
Cross
|
Raceme yield (per plant)
|
Scape length (cm)
|
Raceme length (cm) | |